• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Rabia Gale

undiscovered countries

  • Home
  • Works
    • The Reflected City
    • The Sunless World
    • Taurin’s Chosen
    • Heartwood
    • Stand-Alones
  • Newsletter
  • Blog
  • About Me
  • Contact

about reviewing

Alma Alexander’s post on reviewing writers (as in, writers who review other writers’ books, not the reviewing OF writers) popped up in my RSS feed as I was putting together my June reading roundup. It was timely because I always get this squeamish feeling before posting up reviews that are less than glowing. I like a lot of books, but I LOVE very few of them, and I’m not the sort to call a book “good” unless I really mean it. However, as a wannabe author, am I really brash enough to critique the works of people so far ahead of the game? Writers who have a lot more skill than I do? Writers that I might some day actually *gulp* meet?  Writing a novel is hard work. Knowing that, having experienced that, shouldn’t I be kinder towards other books?

One solution would be to not review books at all, but then you’d have a monthly list of books with no commentary. Or, I could review only the books I liked, and stay nothing about the ones I didn’t. So far, I’ve chosen to post my (tempered) reviews and stand behind my (tempered) opinions.

What say you? Do you read book reviews? What do you look for in a review? Do the rules of the reviewing game change if the reviewer is also a writer? If you do vent about books that push your buttons the wrong way, do you choose to not name them?

Share via email Share

Filed Under: reading, reviews

Get Each Post in Your Inbox

Sign up here to receive each blog post in your inbox.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. LisaM says

    July 16, 2009 at 10:29 am

    As an aiming-to-be-published-one-day writer, I have the same worries. I try to find at least one good thing about each book I read, even if I didn’t enjoy it, and I always make a distinction between the writer and his/her book, but I’m wondering if I should stop reviewing and simply just add the books to my What I’m Reading blog without a commentary unless I have something glowing to write. I’m still not sure, but I’d definitely prefer to err on the side of caution.

    Reply
  2. Rabia says

    July 16, 2009 at 1:20 pm

    *nod* I’m trying to be cautious, too. However, it chafes me to think that I can no longer express my opinions because I’m trying to join the Published Writers Club. OTOH, I prefer to be kind to people, and I have to remember that behind every book is a person who poured sweat and blood and toil into it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Join the Mailing List

I send out monthly newsletters, and share some special content with subscribers only. Join me!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Search

Latest Release

Witchblaze Cover

Witchblaze

Gruesome rites. Whispers of witches. Arabella’s past has caught up to her. Arabella finally feels like she belongs. She’s settled into her role as the Bearer of St. Brigit’s Arcana. She has family, friends, and a purpose. And assisting the Phantasm Bureau has brought her close to handsome viscount Trey Shield, a formidable magician in [read more] about Witchblaze

Recent Posts

A YA anime-inspired web serial

April 30, 2019 Leave a Comment

The Darkest Days Fantasy Bundle

July 10, 2018 Leave a Comment

Now Out: Ghostlight

May 31, 2018 Leave a Comment

Ghostlight, Chapter Two

May 29, 2018 Leave a Comment

Categories

© 2021 Rabia Gale | All Rights Reserved | Design by Robin Cornett | Header Artwork by David Revoy: Used with permission | Privacy Policy